Frozen shoulder symptoms are a deep ache in the shoulder and upper arm, often worse at night, and stiffness in every direction, even when someone else tries to move your arm. The condition passes through three overlapping stages: freezing (2 to 9 months), frozen (4 to 12 months) and thawing (5 to 24 months).
If your shoulder wakes you every night and the seat belt is suddenly out of reach, you already know the first stage. The name describes the middle of the story well and the beginning badly. Before it freezes, the shoulder burns. Doctors call it adhesive capsulitis.
What are the symptoms of frozen shoulder?
Two symptoms define it. The first is pain: a deep, dull ache felt in the shoulder and often down the outside of the upper arm, which flares with sudden movements and gets worse at night. Lying on the affected side becomes impossible for many people.
The second is stiffness, and it is a particular kind. The shoulder loses movement in every direction, and it stays stiff when you relax completely and let someone else lift or turn the arm. Clinicians call this a loss of passive movement. A sore tendon hurts when you use it, but a helper can still move the arm through its range. A frozen shoulder simply stops.
The movement that goes first is usually external rotation: keeping the elbow tucked into your side and turning the forearm outwards. You notice it in everyday tasks long before you notice it in a mirror.
- putting your arm into a coat sleeve or reaching for the seat belt;
- washing or brushing your hair;
- doing up a bra, tucking in a shirt or reaching a back pocket.
Which of the two dominates depends on the stage you are in.
What is frozen shoulder, and who gets it?
The shoulder joint is wrapped in a fibrous sleeve called the capsule. When the arm hangs, the capsule is loose and forms a generous fold underneath the joint. That spare tissue is what lets the arm rise above your head and turn outwards.
In frozen shoulder, the capsule becomes inflamed, thickens, and then contracts. The joint surfaces themselves stay healthy, which is why the X-ray is normal. A normal X-ray is in fact one of the criteria for the diagnosis.
Estimates put frozen shoulder at under 1% to 2% of the population. In the large Oxford cohort followed by Hand and colleagues, symptoms began at an average age of 53, and women outnumbered men by 1.6 to 1. The peak age overlaps with the menopause, which is why so many women search for a link. A direct hormonal cause has not been shown.
The three stages of frozen shoulder, and how long each lasts
The idea of stages dates back to the 1940s. The first study to time them properly was published by Reeves in 1975: 41 patients followed for 5 to 10 years, until their best recovery. The whole episode lasted 30 months on average, far longer than the 18 months quoted at the time. The longer the stiff stage lasted, the longer recovery took.
THE THREE STAGES OF FROZEN SHOULDER, TO SCALE
01 · Freezing
2 to 9 months
The capsule is inflamed. Pain dominates, above all at night.
02 · Frozen
4 to 12 months
Inflammation settles, the scarred capsule locks the shoulder.
03 · Thawing
5 to 24 months
The capsule loosens and movement slowly returns.
The ranges below come from the 2020 meta-analysis by Challoumas and colleagues, as rough guides rather than a calendar.
| Stage | Usual length | What dominates | What helps at this point |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Freezing, or painful | 2 to 9 months | Sharp pain, worst at night; movement starts to go | Calming the inflammation: steroid injection, pain relief, gentle movement below the pain threshold |
| 2. Frozen, or stiff | 4 to 12 months | Pain eases, the shoulder stays blocked in every direction | Keeping the range you have with gradual self-stretches, never forced |
| 3. Thawing | 5 to 24 months | Movement returns bit by bit, pain only at the end of range | More active physiotherapy, strengthening, back to normal tasks |
Stage 1: freezing
This is the hardest stage, and the most misleading. Early on, the shoulder still moves and the pain looks like a tendon problem. It wakes you at night, stops you sleeping on that side, and any sudden movement sends a jolt that takes your breath away. Stiffness creeps in at the same time, over a few weeks, often unnoticed.
Stage 2: frozen
The pain fades and nights become bearable again. The shoulder, though, feels welded. To lift your arm you shrug the shoulder blade without thinking. Many people only see a GP at this point. That is a pity, because the trials behind steroid injection mostly involved shoulders that had been painful for less than a year.
Stage 3: thawing, and what is left afterwards
Movement returns, slowly. The promise of a complete recovery on its own, repeated on most websites, does not always hold. In Oxford, 223 patients were reviewed an average of 4.4 years after their symptoms began: 59% had a normal or near-normal shoulder, 41% still had some symptoms, mild in 94% of cases, and 6% had severe symptoms, with pain and loss of function. Those with the worst pain at the start did least well.
Frozen shoulder is benign. It is not, for all that, something you simply sit out.
Why does the shoulder become inflamed, then stiff?
Biopsies tell the story. In 2007 the Oxford team examined capsule tissue from 22 patients who needed surgery after other treatments failed, on average 15 months after their symptoms began. The tissue was full of multiplying fibroblasts and cells of chronic inflammation: mainly mast cells, along with T and B lymphocytes and macrophages. Even that late, frozen shoulder is still an inflammatory condition.
FROM INFLAMMATION TO A LOCKED SHOULDER
The process resembles a scar that contracts.
What starts it is less clear. A minor knock, a period in a sling after a fracture or an operation, sometimes nothing at all. The background that makes it more likely is far better understood.
Diabetes, thyroid and the other shoulder: who is most at risk?
Diabetes is the best established risk factor by a wide margin. A meta-analysis by Zreik and colleagues put a number on it.
The risk of frozen shoulder in someone with diabetes, compared with someone without it. Among people with diabetes, 13.4% were found to have one.
Meta-analysis by Zreik et al., Muscles, Ligaments and Tendons Journal, 2016.
Seen the other way round, nearly 30% of people with frozen shoulder have diabetes. The authors’ advice follows: anyone who sees a doctor for frozen shoulder should be checked for it.
The likeliest explanation is the sugar itself. When blood glucose stays high, glucose binds to collagen and forms cross-links that stiffen it, the advanced glycation end products. The same compounds keep a low level of inflammation going for as long as glucose stays high.
The thyroid comes next. In a Brazilian study of 93 people with frozen shoulder and 151 controls, an underactive thyroid affected 27.2% of patients against 10.7% of controls. The highest TSH levels went with the most severe cases and with both shoulders being affected.
Then come long periods with the arm held still, after a broken wrist or surgery to the shoulder or breast. And the other shoulder: in the Oxford follow-up, one patient in five had both sides affected, yet no shoulder that had recovered froze again. If you have had a frozen shoulder before, night pain on the other side is worth mentioning to your GP early.
Frozen shoulder or a rotator cuff problem?
The two are easily confused at first, because both hurt in the same place and both wake you at night. Passive movement settles it. With shoulder tendinopathy, the tendon hurts when you use it, but if someone lifts your relaxed arm, it goes up. With frozen shoulder it does not go up, however gently the other person pushes: the capsule is what blocks it.
| What you notice | Frozen shoulder | Rotator cuff tendinopathy | Subacromial bursitis |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is affected | The joint capsule | One or more cuff tendons | The bursa over the cuff |
| Arm lifted by someone else | Blocked in every direction | Goes up, sometimes painfully | Goes up, sometimes painfully |
| Turning the forearm outwards | Much reduced, often the first sign | Kept | Kept |
| Night pain | Very common, above all in stage 1 | Common, lying on that side | Common, lying on that side |
| X-ray | Normal | Normal, sometimes a calcium deposit | Normal |
| Course | Three stages, often more than a year | Improves with progressive loading | Quick when acute, slower if a tendon is involved |
The three can coexist, and shoulder bursitis often accompanies an irritated tendon. But neither the tendon nor the bursa blocks passive outward rotation. If yours has gone, the capsule moves to the top of the list.
A simple check, sitting down: elbows tucked in at your sides and bent to a right angle, turn both forearms outwards. If the painful side stops well short of the other, and a helper’s hand cannot take it further, the capsule is the probable cause. It does not replace an examination: shoulder arthritis or an old dislocation can block the joint the same way, hence the X-ray.
Which treatments actually shorten a frozen shoulder?
None makes it vanish in a few days. Some ease the pain sooner, some help movement return, and very few have been shown to shorten the whole episode. On the NHS, the usual sequence is pain relief, then physiotherapy, with a steroid injection when the pain is strong.
A steroid injection, the earlier the better
This is the best supported option. The Challoumas meta-analysis pooled 65 trials and 4,097 participants: only a steroid injection into the joint beat the alternatives in the short term, for pain and for function, with a benefit lasting up to 6 months. The authors suggest offering it at the first appointment when symptoms have lasted less than a year, always with home exercises.
The logic matches the biopsies. The steroid dampens the inflammation while it dominates, before collagen has set the capsule. Later on it still eases pain, but lost movement comes back mainly through movement.
Hydrodilatation, or hydrodistension
Several NHS trusts offer it: under X-ray or ultrasound guidance, a large volume of fluid, usually with a steroid, is injected to stretch the capsule. The gains are modest. In the Saltychev meta-analysis of 7 trials, the effect on pain and movement was small, 12 patients needed treating for one to benefit, and disability did not change significantly. It is worth discussing when a shoulder stays very stiff after a simple injection.
Physiotherapy, gentle first
In the freezing stage, forcing the shoulder gains no movement and stirs the pain up again. Useful exercises stay below the pain threshold: pendulum swings, raising the arm with help from the other hand, turning the forearm outwards with a stick. A few minutes several times a day beats one long session. In the Challoumas analysis, adding this home programme to an injection could improve the medium-term result further. Harder work with a physiotherapist belongs to the thawing stage. In some areas you can refer yourself to NHS physiotherapy without seeing a GP first.
Surgery: what the UK FROST trial found
Manipulation under anaesthesia and keyhole capsular release are reserved for shoulders that stay locked after months of well-run treatment. The UK FROST trial, run in 35 NHS hospitals, compared them with early structured physiotherapy plus a steroid injection in 503 adults. At 12 months the three groups scored 38.3 (manipulation), 40.3 (capsular release) and 37.2 (physiotherapy) on the 48-point Oxford Shoulder Score. None of the differences was large enough to matter clinically. Capsular release had 8 serious adverse events against 2 for manipulation, and manipulation was the most cost-effective.
What should you avoid with a frozen shoulder?
The freezing stage is when your own choices count most. Three mistakes come up again and again.
Keeping the arm in a sling all day is the first. Immobility feeds the very contraction you are trying to avoid. The second is forcing it: home-made stretching routines and gym machines, which the NHS specifically warns can make the pain worse. The third is waiting a year before seeing anyone, when an injection works best in the first months.
Nights deserve their own plan. An arm that hangs or gets trapped under you wakes the pain. A pillow under the elbow and forearm, lying on your back or on the good side, often calms it. The positions that ease shoulder pain at night work for frozen shoulder too. During the day, a heat pack wrapped in a tea towel for up to 20 minutes, and paracetamol taken regularly, are what the NHS suggests first.
If you have diabetes, keeping your blood glucose steady is part of the treatment. Some people also choose to support the inflammatory background through diet or a supplement. That is the role of a standardised joint formula combining curcumin, boswellia, ginger, quercetin and alpha-lipoic acid: it accompanies the injection and the exercises, it does not replace them. It is not recommended for people with diabetes, close to a third of those with frozen shoulder, nor with anticoagulants, in pregnancy or with bile duct problems. Ask your GP or pharmacist first.
When to get help quickly
A red, hot, swollen shoulder with fever, pain that never changes with movement or rest, unexplained weight loss, or an arm that has become weak after a fall: none of these are frozen shoulder, and they need prompt assessment. If pain in the left shoulder comes with tightness in the chest or breathlessness, call 999.
Frequently asked questions
How long does frozen shoulder last?
Usually between one and three years. The freezing stage lasts 2 to 9 months, the frozen stage 4 to 12 months and the thawing stage 5 to 24 months, with overlaps. In the first long follow-up study the whole episode averaged 30 months, and 41% of patients in an Oxford cohort still had some symptoms after 4.4 years.
How painful is a frozen shoulder on a scale of 1 to 10?
There is no fixed score, and pain varies a great deal from one person to the next. It is worst in the freezing stage, when it can wake you every night and a sudden movement causes a sharp, breath-catching jolt. It eases in the frozen stage, when stiffness takes over. Pain that never changes with rest or movement needs checking.
What should you not do with frozen shoulder?
Do not keep the arm still in a sling, which feeds the stiffness, and do not force it with home-made stretches or gym machines, which the NHS warns can make the pain worse. Avoid lying on the painful side. And do not wait a year to see a GP: a steroid injection works best in the first months.
How long does it take to recover from frozen shoulder surgery?
Both operations, manipulation under anaesthesia and capsular release, are followed by physiotherapy, up to 12 sessions over 12 weeks in the UK FROST trial. At one year, operated shoulders scored 38 to 40 out of 48 on the Oxford Shoulder Score, close to the 37 reached with physiotherapy plus a steroid injection alone.
What are some home remedies for a frozen shoulder?
Gentle pendulum swings several times a day, a heat pack wrapped in a towel for up to 20 minutes, paracetamol taken regularly, and a pillow under the elbow at night. Keep using the arm for light tasks. Home care eases the pain, but it does not replace an assessment if nights stay broken for weeks.
Sources
Reeves B. (1975). The natural history of the frozen shoulder syndrome. Scandinavian Journal of Rheumatology, 4(4), 193-196. DOI: 10.3109/03009747509165255
Hand G.C.R., Athanasou N.A., Matthews T., Carr A.J. (2007). The pathology of frozen shoulder. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, British volume, 89(7), 928-932. DOI: 10.1302/0301-620X.89B7.19097
Hand C., Clipsham K., Rees J.L., Carr A.J. (2008). Long-term outcome of frozen shoulder. Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery, 17(2), 231-236. DOI: 10.1016/j.jse.2007.05.009
Zreik N.H., Malik R.A., Charalambous C.P. (2016). Adhesive capsulitis of the shoulder and diabetes: a meta-analysis of prevalence. Muscles, Ligaments and Tendons Journal, 6(1), 26-34. DOI: 10.11138/mltj/2016.6.1.026
Schiefer M., Teixeira P.F.S., Fontenelle C. et al. (2017). Prevalence of hypothyroidism in patients with frozen shoulder. Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery, 26(1), 49-55. DOI: 10.1016/j.jse.2016.04.026
Challoumas D., Biddle M., McLean M., Millar N.L. (2020). Comparison of treatments for frozen shoulder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Network Open, 3(12), e2029581. DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.29581
Saltychev M., Laimi K., Virolainen P., Fredericson M. (2018). Effectiveness of hydrodilatation in adhesive capsulitis of shoulder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Scandinavian Journal of Surgery, 107(4), 285-293. DOI: 10.1177/1457496918772367
Rangan A., Brealey S.D., Keding A. et al. (2020). Management of adults with primary frozen shoulder in secondary care (UK FROST): a multicentre, pragmatic, three-arm, superiority randomised clinical trial. The Lancet, 396(10256), 977-989. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(20)31965-6